Evolution
Evolution is the metamorphosis of one piñata species into another. A piñata can evolve by a wide variety of methods, usually related to eating something. The ability to evolve is limited to a select few species of piñata. The only species that can evolve into multiple species is the White Flutterscotch, however none of these evolutions count towards the Evolver or Master Evolver achievements.

Evolving Species
| Base species | Evolution method | Evolved species | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Classic | TIP | ||||
| Syrupent | Hit egg with shovel just before hatching | Twingersnap | |||
| Twingersnap | Hit egg with shovel just before hatching | Fourheads | |||
| Quackberry | Eat a Gooseberry | Juicygoose | |||
| Lickatoad | Eat a Nightshade Berry, then hit it with a shovel while it's confused | Lackatoad | |||
| Taffly | Set on fire with a firebrand, then douse with a watering can | Reddhott | |||
| Newtgat | Eat a chili | Salamango | |||
| Horstachio | Eat a daisy and a blackberry | Zumbug | |||
| Sparrowmint | Eat a Buttercup | Eat a Dandelion | Candary | ||
| Cluckles | N/A | Eat 2 cactus seeds | Chocstrich | ||
| Doenut | N/A | Eat a fir seed | Moojoo | ||
| Rashberry | N/A | Eat a cheesecake | Hoghurt | ||
| Fudgehog | N/A | Eat a coconut | Parmadillo | ||
| Pretztail | N/A | Eat a bone | Pieena | ||
| Fizzlybear | N/A | Eat a blue gem | Polollybear | ||
White Flutterscotch has 9 different variants it can evolve into after eating certain flowers. These variants are mostly treated as separate species by the game, however they do not count towards any evolution based achievements.
| Flutterscotch | Method | |
|---|---|---|
| Brown Flutterscotch | Has eaten a bullrush | |
| Red Flutterscotch | Has eaten a poppy | |
| Orange Flutterscotch | Has eaten a bird of paradise | |
| Yellow Flutterscotch | Has eaten a buttercup | |
| Green Flutterscotch | Has eaten a watercress | |
| Blue Flutterscotch | Has eaten a bluebell | |
| Pink Flutterscotch | Has eaten a water lily | |
| Purple Flutterscotch | Has eaten a thistle | |
| Black Flutterscotch | Has eaten a tulip | |
Trivia
- While the Syrupent family does not evolve in the traditional sense (i.e. a Syrupent itself cannot evolve into a Twingersnap), the method for hatching a Twingersnap (and Fourheads) is classified in-game as an evolution method.