Accessories are various types of articles of clothing that can be worn by piñatas, available for sale at Paper Pets. Wearing accessories not only makes piñatas happier, but raises their value as well. Each piñata can wear up to 5 different accessories-- no more than one per part of the body. Accessories can be worn on the head, eyes, mouth, ears, neck, nose, arms, feet, body, and front.

While many accessories are purely cosmetic, many also have other uses. This can range from fulfilling romance requirements, to allowing certain species to produce automatically. Piñatas wearing specific accessories are also commonly requested for Langston's Challenges in Trouble in Paradise.

In Pocket Paradise, accessories are instead sold by Gretchen Fetchum, along with all other functionality from Paper Pets.

Dragonache and Choclodocus are the only species that cannot wear accessories at all. Sour piñatas also cannot wear accessories, as they cannot in reside permanently in garden without first being tamed.